Lords committee warns UK is underprepared for growing national resilience risks

The UK is seriously underprepared for major national emergencies and interconnected threats, with government leadership, local coordination and critical infrastructure protection requiring urgent improvement, according to a report by the House of Lords National Resilience Committee.

image: House of Lords National Resilience Committee

The report, Are we ready? Building a culture of resilience, published following a nine-month inquiry, argues that existing arrangements are too fragmented and frequently focus on individual emergencies rather than the potential for multiple crises to occur simultaneously and intensify one another.

The committee identifies a range of threats, including cyber attacks, hostile state activity, disruption to critical infrastructure, extreme weather, supply-chain failures and the possibility of military conflict. It warns that disruption in one sector could have cascading consequences across essential services, exposing weaknesses in the UK's preparedness.

A central recommendation is the appointment of a Cabinet minister with sole responsibility for national resilience, supported by a Chief Resilience Officer at Permanent Secretary level. The committee also wants the government to establish a single national resilience strategy within six months, setting out clear responsibilities, common standards and measurable objectives for national, regional and local organisations.

The report highlights weaknesses in translating national policy into local action. It recommends establishing regional coordination centres to improve the flow of information and resources between central government and local responders, and placing Local Resilience Forums on a statutory footing with defined responsibilities and sustainable funding.

The committee also calls for greater involvement of businesses and operators of critical infrastructure in national preparedness. It recommends a tiered framework of resilience requirements, including statutory preparedness and business continuity duties for organisations whose continued operation is essential to national resilience. Regular cross-sector stress tests should examine how well government, businesses and local responders could maintain essential services during major disruption.

Transport, energy, water, communications and other critical infrastructure sectors are particularly relevant to the committee's concerns about interdependencies. The report argues that resilience planning needs to consider the continued operation of essential national functions, rather than concentrating on individual organisations or risks.

Supply-chain vulnerabilities are another area of concern. The committee recommends strengthening domestic production and strategic reserves of essential goods, particularly medicines, food and agricultural inputs, while diversifying international supply arrangements. It also calls for better arrangements to protect water supplies during prolonged disruption.

On digital and communications infrastructure, the report warns that dependence on interconnected technologies creates additional vulnerabilities. It recommends widening the scope of cyber security regulation, strengthening domestic expertise in emerging technologies and ensuring that critical infrastructure operators have access to relevant threat intelligence.

It also calls for tested backup communications arrangements in the event of widespread power outages, disruption to subsea cables or other interference. Among its more specific recommendations is that the government should abandon plans to switch off Digital Terrestrial Television, arguing that older communications technologies could remain important during emergencies when digital systems fail.

The committee further recommends that the government publish its performance against NATO's seven civil preparedness baseline requirements, explaining where the UK falls short and how identified gaps will be addressed.

Public preparedness is also addressed. The report welcomes the government's three-year Be Ready campaign but argues that it needs to form part of a longer-term approach. Recommendations include providing every household with a preparedness booklet, developing a multilingual emergency app and embedding resilience education and practical skills throughout life.

Baroness Coussins, chair of the National Resilience Committee, said the UK needed to connect its plans, protect essential services and make preparedness part of everyday life.

The findings come as the government seeks to strengthen national security and civil preparedness in response to a more challenging international security environment. The committee acknowledges recent initiatives, including the Be Ready campaign and increased national exercising, but argues that these need to be supported by clearer accountability, sustained investment and more effective coordination.

Next
Next

Government sets out roadmap to accelerate clean electrification across UK economy